Site menu:

Archives

Search the Archives

Follow me!

Links:

When You’re Not the Only One Who Likes Him

A reader named Anxious is, uh, anxious. Man, what a lucky break that is, huh? If she anxious was named “totally relaxed” it would just be weird, right? Huh? Huh?

Ok, here’s the thing. She’s just started dating a guy and she really likes him. Trouble is, she’s not the only one who likes him. An old friend of his has made HER intentions known. What can Anxious do? How can she know what he’s thinking?

No worries, Anx, I’ve got this one covered.

I’ve been casually dating a guy for about a month. By casual I mean we see each other once or twice a week, and generally talk (via email or text)maybe 5 days a week? Always initiated by him.

Sounds like a good, casual, fun start. And it’s a good sign that he’s initiating. Good, understandable, readable material there. It says, “I like spending time talking to you, so I’m-a keep doin’ it.

He recently got out of a relationship – and though we’ve both expressed feelings for each other, neither of us want to rush into anything.

Good idea. Then again, last time I said that was when I began dating my, you know, wife, so don’t go by me.

Now that he is newly single, his best female friend confessed HER feelings for him. He told me all of this – and that they are just friends. I know it’s a good sign he is honest with me, but I can’t help but be jealous and feel  threatened.

Yes, both of those things are right. It IS a good sign that he’s telling you about this — it would be a very NOT good sign if you found out that he’d been hiding this. And yes, of course it’s going to feel weird and threatening, especially since you’ve just started dating.

If we continue dating like this for a few months, or this situation eventually turns into a relationship – I don’t know if I can ever be comfortable knowing this girl is “waiting” for him to come around. (oh and she said she would wait…)

Are you saying…you’re gonna have her whacked? Because otherwise, you might have to deal with the fact that she’s waiting. But remember, she’s not your problem. It’s about him. (More on that in a minute.)

There will be times when I don’t hear from him for a day or two, and I’m trying to be okay with that now that I know her motives- but I know they talk daily. I also know that she initiates more than I do.

The good news is that more initiating is not what makes a man fall in love with you. Oh and less initiating doesn’t either. It just sorta happens. Put another way, if he doesn’t like her, she can call all day long — she’s not going to “wear him down.” There’s no convincing here. And if he does like her? Well, nothing anybody can do about that either.

I’m not sure how or if I should draw the line and walk away – and am scared I’m running away from something too soon that with time, could turn out really great.

What do I do and how Do I know if I should trust him? (i.e. if actions speak louder than words – what actions should I keep an eye out for?).

Dear Anxious,

Ok, tough situation, right? It’s early, so what right do you have to dictate who he spends time with? And at ANY stage, “dictating” isn’t a great idea. Unless he’s your secretary in the 1950s, which I’ll go ahead and assume he’s not.

Here are a couple of things to think about.

  1. THE OTHER WOMAN HAS NO POWER OVER HIM. No, no, I mean it. She’s got no magical powers. If he is interested in her, well, that’s how it is. She can’t make him do that.
  2. ER…NEITHER DO YOU: You can’t make him like you. You can’t make him stop being friends with her. What you CAN do is make him think that you’re a jealous, controlling person who is more trouble than you’re worth by constantly checking up on him with this other woman. That, you can do.

So, what do you do? How can you tell he’s interested in you (and not her)? First, here are a few things to watch out for, conveniently titled…

A FEW THINGS TO WATCH OUT FOR

  • SECRECY: The good news is, he’s already showing you that he’s not interested in this one. If a guy is with one woman but likes another, he’s likely not going to talk about the other woman.
  • DISTANCE: If, when you’re with him, it feels like he’s someplace else, this isn’t a great sign. Again, this is not about HER, it’s about HIM. You want a guy who, when he’s with you, he is really with you, focused on you, eager to spend time with YOU. Again, sounds like he’s on board with this one as well.
  • BS EXCUSES: If this guy start’s being “crazy busy” or just can’t seem to find the time to be with you, well, that’s never a good sign. Doesn’t sound like you’re describing one of those. 2 days between contact isn’t so bad that it’s suspicious to me.

Now, if these all sound a little bit like stuff to watch out for to determine the health of ANY relationship, that’s not a coincidence. One more time — this problem is not about HER. It’s about whether or not he likes you. If he does, she can’t screw that up. And if she tries, he’ll be annoyed with her, not “convinced.” And if he doesn’t, well, game over anyway.

SO WHAT CAN YOU DO?

I would say this. The number one thing you should do in this (or really any new  relationship) is to, as best you can, KEEP THE AIRLOCK OPEN.

I use that metaphor a lot, and I think it makes a ton of sense early on. In fact, I’d say that’s the best thing that my enwifened lady faire and I did from the very beginning. No walls up, no major defenses. It was either going to work, or it wasn’t, as is. Like I said, I had just gotten out of a relationship, and I didn’t have the energy to bother with all of the games.

I went out on a few dates with a few women, and it was simply not possible to keep the airlock open with them. We weren’t a good fit, so buh-bye, right? With Liz, it was impossible not to, even if we’d tried.

Now, that’s the downside of keeping the airlocks open — if it’s not going to work out, well, you’re gonna find out about it. Like, pronto. But if you guys ARE a match, this kind of relaxed, open communication is what you’ll be able to give him that no one else will.

Good luck, Anxious. I know it feels lousy when there’s competition for your person. But really, I swear, there isn’t any. Not really. If he’s your guy, there’s nothing she can do about it.

What can she do to see what he’s doing, ladies? Should she be worried?

Why not buy my BOOK? Huh?

Comments

Comment from AnneZ
Time January 14, 2009 at 10:19 am

Excellent advice, Jeff.

Comment from Gigity
Time January 14, 2009 at 10:24 am

Jeff…you are great! I’m so glad I randomly found your blog. I now have it bookmarked and check in daily for objective advice from a male point of view.

Comment from Sara
Time January 15, 2009 at 12:48 am

I double what Gigity says. Perfect advice. If you don’t trust the guy, how can you have a good relationship, whether or not this woman holds any significance for him? Give him the chance to prove himself by being patient and open-minded and see where he wants to steer the relationship, especially since he already initiates communication. I’d say give it time, don’t run from the good guys =p That’s why so many guys say “nice guys finish last”. He was honest with you about the girl, and you have to reward that behavior by not being suspicious when you have no reason.

Could be a winner! Hang in there!

Comment from Ellen
Time January 15, 2009 at 11:04 pm

Excellent advice. Also, if Anxious and her guy stay together and enter a committed relationship, she should make an effort to befriend his best gal pal. If Gal Pal’s important enough to him to be his best friend, Anxious should embrace her, not be threatened by her.

Comment from The Seductress Within
Time January 20, 2009 at 1:18 pm

Jeff gave great advice.

I would add to that…I actually find it odd that after one month of casually dating he felt the need to tell her this.

If he mentions the friend’s attraction to him again just tell him that you’d totally understand if he wants to take that friendship to a new level….and remain unaffected. It’s possible that while he’s not interested in her, he wanted to provoke a little jealousy. Don’t feed that behavior.

Remain the happy, confident person as always.

If he likes her or wants to try dating her, you will know soon.

Comment from leesa
Time January 29, 2009 at 12:58 am

I think Anxious is in the best possible position for an excellent outcome.

If this other lady is quite open in expressing her interest to the guy, and they talk daily, then she’s going to be putting quite the heavy on him.

The guy, who had have been with her a long time ago if he had any interest in seeing her, will probably quickly tire of her behaviour.

If she can’t keep it at a friend level, which sounds likely if she’s that open and insistant on “waiting” for him, then their friendship is likely to diminish.

So all Anxious has to do, is sit back and wait. :)

Comment from Melissa
Time January 29, 2009 at 12:39 pm

First of all, “Anxious” should stop using that name to describe herself in this scenario. Words have much more power than we realize, you don’t want to condition yourself in any negative way. Even if it’s only to yourself….self talk is very potent. Especially when you need to keep your wits about you!!

The good news here is:
1. If he was really into his best friend, HE would have made this Crystal Clear to HER, not the other way around.
2. She told him she would “wait” for him….hmmm….not a smart move on her part…it would impress him more if she was on the ball in her dating life, lending evidence that She would be the catch. She also put pressure on him with that declaration.
3. She knows about you, so she probably feel compelled to “over-do”, meaning bending over backwards with actions and speech to Convince him to Choose Her. You should be in a “leaning back” mode…letting him do the initiating, leading the dance, etc. Do not allow yourself to feel so pressured that you Over-give.

It’s often amazing…the less you do, the more you get in certain situation. Picture a bicycle wheel, for example…the outer part of the wheel, the tire, does the most work. The center of the tire (is there a name for it?) does hardly anything and still gleans the same result! Am I saying “be lazy in your life” no, of course not. I’m saying be selective of how you think and act here.
4. Seductress is right…if he mentions his friend’s interest again, he may be fishing…I would recommend Seductress’ response. He would totally not expect that.

Alot of men have expectations of how women behave in different scenarios from previous experiences, their own and others. And, sadly, they don’t always reflect positively on us females. Take the high road and behave confidently, based on his actions. If he all of a sudden pulls back (not saying he will), then YOU pull back and be busy, too. Do not pursue him and give him the third degree.
5. Since this relationship is only 1 month old, are you keeping your dating options open?

Good Skill, and keep a cool head. Think before you act! (Again, most men don’t expect this…the element of surprise can often work in your favor ;)

All my best,
Melissa

Write a comment